Dissenting Shareholder Loses Right to Receive Dividends Upon Merger Consummation
Like most states, New York's Business Corporation Law (BCL) permits a shareholder to opt out of mergers and certain other corporate restructurings by electing to be cashed out for the "fair value" of his or her shares. The so-called dissenting shareholder statute, BCL Section 623, sets forth procedures and deadlines for submission of the shareholder's written objection to the proposed transaction, for the corporation's making of a price offer, and for the filing of a judicial appraisal proceeding in the event the shareholder rejects the corporation's offer. A statutory appraisal proceeding also may result from a "freeze-out merger" in which the controlling shareholders compel minority shareholders to redeem their shares for cash. The dissenting shareholder statute typically comes into play with merger transactions involving corporations with relatively large capitalization and whose minority shareholders include passive investors. Section 1005 of the New York Limited Liability Company Law likewise permits members to dissent and cash out from mergers or consolidations involving LLC's.
A recent court decision, in a case called McCully v. Jersey Partners, Inc., 18 Misc 3d 1138(A) (Sup Ct NY Co 2008), raises a caution flag for dissenting shareholders and their counsel when it comes to asserting claims for dividends that accrue prior to merger consummation but are not payable until afterward.
Continue Reading...