This week’s New York Business Divorce treats valuation aficionados to summaries of four recent stock appraisal decisions that made it to the Supreme Court of four different states.
Continue Reading Recent Stock Valuation Decisions Reign “Supreme”
Should courts apply a marketability discount in determining the fair value of interests in realty holding companies? In downstate New York, the answer may vary depending on whether the court lies within the First or Second Departments of the Appellate Division. This week’s New York Business Divorce has the story.
Continue Reading A River’s Divide: Time for the Manhattan and Brooklyn Appellate Courts to Agree on Marketability Discount in Fair Value Proceedings
A minority partner paid a heavy price for wrongfully dissolving the partnership in an appellate ruling last week applying a 66% minority discount — along with marketability and goodwill discounts and offsets for damages — to the value of the partner’s interest. It’s in this week’s New York Business Divorce.
Continue Reading Partner Who Wrongfully Dissolved Partnership Hit With Whopping 66% Minority Discount
This week’s New York Business Divorce traces New York’s endorsement of the marketability discount in fair value proceedings to its first application in 1982 by a court-appointed Referee named Sam Tripp — my grandfather!
Continue Reading The Birthing of New York’s Marketability Discount in Fair Value Cases: A Family Affair
Do New York courts in fair value proceedings unfairly apply a marketability discount at the shareholder level? The author of a recently published article thinks so, as you’ll learn in this week’s New York Business Divorce.
Continue Reading The DLOM Debate Heats Up
In the second of two posts on the recent post-trial decision in Chiu v. Chiu, involving the disputed ownership of a single-asset real estate holding company, this week’s New York Business Divorce focuses on the court’s rejection of a discount for lack of marketability in determining the fair value of the withdrawing member’s 10% interest.
Continue Reading Court Rejects Marketability Discount in LLC Fair Value Case
Stock valuation aficionados will not want to miss the report in this week’s New York Business Divorce on the recent decision in Matter of Harlem River Yard Ventures, Inc. It’s a dissenting shareholder case triggered by a squeeze-out merger in which the court was faced with widely disparate expert valuations of a company holding a 99-year lease on the Bronx site of the former Penn Central rail yards, now serving as an industrial park.
Continue Reading Court Endorses Discounted Cash Flow Method, Rejects Post-Merger Tax Benefits, in Determining Fair Value Award to Dissenting Shareholder
The discount for lack of marketability is a fixture in New York fair value jurisprudence as a result of almost 30 years of case law starting with Matter of Blake. Some prominent voices in the business valuation field are challenging the doctrine as wrong in theory and bereft of empirical support. Learn more in this week’s New York Business Divorce.
Continue Reading The Marketability Discount in Fair Value Proceedings: An Emperor Without Clothes?
This week’s New York Business Divorce examines a noteworthy decision by Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Marylin Diamond in Cole v. Macklowe, where she precluded the defendant’s valuation expert from testifying on the applicability of minority and marketability discounts in valuing the plaintiff’s equity interests in a series of single-asset real estate holding companies.
Continue Reading Court Rejects Minority and Marketability Discounts in Assessing Damages for Breach of Equity Participation Agreement