There are arguments pro and con when it comes to the power to expel a/k/a dissociate an LLC member. On the one hand, expulsion can be viewed as a necessary measure to preserve the LLC as a going concern when faced with persistent misconduct or failure to perform by one of its members. On the other hand, depending how broadly or narrowly the expulsion criteria are drawn, the power to expel can be a tool of oppression and abuse by those wielding it for their self-advantage.
Expulsion can occur in one of two ways. First, the operating agreement can authorize member expulsion under specified circumstances by self-executing action of the other members or managers. This is not a feature I regularly come across in operating agreements of LLCs, especially those whose membership consists of founding owners actively involved in the business.
Second, in states that have adopted the Revised Uniform LLC Act — to date numbering 16 plus the District of Columbia; New York is not one of them — courts are authorized to expel an LLC member on application by the company or a member on three specified grounds, two of which entail fault-based standards based on intentionally wrongful conduct or material breach, and the third of which dispenses with the notion of wrongful conduct by authorizing judicial expulsion of a member who
has engaged or is engaging in conduct relating to the company’s activities and affairs which makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the activities and affairs with the person as a member.
Not surprisingly, the open-endedness of the above provision when utilized in LLC disputes has generated litigation, with New Jersey courts taking the lead. Last week, in IE Test, LLC v Carroll, 2016 WL 4086260 [NJ Sup Ct Aug. 2, 2016], that state’s Supreme Court handed down a major decision in which it reversed the lower courts’ summary judgment order expelling an LLC member and adopted a series of factors to assist trial courts in determining whether it is not reasonably practicable to operate an LLC in light of a subject member’s conduct. Continue Reading New Jersey Supreme Court Raises the Bar for Judicial Expulsion of LLC Members