A new First Department decision proves once again that no one can agree on the Discount for Lack of Marketability.
Continue Reading The Valuation Discount That No One Can Agree On, Still
The Valuation Discount That No One Can Agree On, Still
Second Department Denies Judicial Dissolution of Realty Holding Limited Partnership (and Related Claims), Ending 22-Count Dispute
When an aggrieved party feels his or her back against the wall, there is a strong temptation to assert every claim under the sun against the adversary. Offense is the best defense, so they say. But when the claims don’t stick, litigants may find that more isn’t necessarily more… but it sure can tie up a case for years, particularly in the backlogged Second Department.
Today’s case—Waldorf Invs. L.P. v Waldorf—offers a solid back-to-basics review of the issues that can be litigated when a limited partnership goes south (and the viability of those claims), but at the cost, figuratively and literally, of 8 years of litigation.Continue Reading Second Department Denies Judicial Dissolution of Realty Holding Limited Partnership (and Related Claims), Ending 22-Count Dispute
Score Another Round for the Estate: First Department Upholds Right of Deceased LLC Member’s Executor to Pursue Member Rights
A recent appellate ruling provides the perfect excuse for revisiting a favorite topic, namely the powers of an estate representative of a deceased LLC member.
Continue Reading Score Another Round for the Estate: First Department Upholds Right of Deceased LLC Member’s Executor to Pursue Member Rights
Indecision Has a Price: Withdraw Lawsuit, Pay Hefty Fee Award
After three years of litigation, can a petitioner abruptly withdraw a business dissolution proceeding without consequences? A recent decision from Justice Reed in the New York County Commercial Division answers that question with a decisive “No.”
Continue Reading Indecision Has a Price: Withdraw Lawsuit, Pay Hefty Fee Award
Too Much Spin on the Numbers: What a Law Firm Breakup Teaches About Valuation Disputes
This week’s post shows that when it comes to business valuations, a little air adds lift—but too much and credibility goes pop.
Deal or No Deal, the Moxy Hotel Edition (or, The Joint Venture That Never Was)
You can’t have a business divorce without first having a business marriage.
Simple enough, right? But, a number of cases we’ve featured on this blog involve the central question of whether the parties, in fact, formed a business relationship… and the attendant difficulties in litigating those types of disputes. Specifically, in a post not too
How Easily Can an Operating Agreement Supplant the Default Rule for LLC Manager Removal? Pretty Easily.
This week on New York Business Divorce, read about the interplay between statutory and contract rules for LLC manager removal or expulsion, set within an appeal from a trio of decisions we wrote about what feels like a lifetime ago.
The Bad Faith Defense to Opportunistic Expulsion
Think bad faith can save you from expulsion? A new ruling shows just how slim that lifeline really is.
Continue Reading The Bad Faith Defense to Opportunistic Expulsion
Does This California Case Bolster the Argument Against Waiver of the Right to Seek Judicial Dissolution of New York LLCs?
A recent California case may shed light on how New York courts should handle ant-dissolution provisions in LLC agreements.
Continue Reading Does This California Case Bolster the Argument Against Waiver of the Right to Seek Judicial Dissolution of New York LLCs?
Second Department Ends Sisters’ Fight Over Family Home Not With a Bang, But a Whimper
Four sisters. One house. Who owns it?
Today’s case delves into a thorny situation many closely-held family businesses struggle with—proving ownership.
It’s no secret that many closely-held family business do not comply with corporate formalities. In the absence of such formalities, it can be difficult to demonstrate ownership without stock certificates in hand, or other